raw step payloads
{
"evaluations": [
{
"atoms": [
{
"text": "Stockholm's city transport office evaluated the 2006 congestion-charge trial using toll-gantry traffic counts.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s1_a1"
},
{
"text": "Stockholm's city transport office evaluation found that inner-city traffic in Stockholm dropped by about 20% almost immediately after the 2006 congestion-charge trial began.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s1_a2"
},
{
"text": "Stockholm's city transport office evaluation found that the traffic reduction persisted after the congestion charge was made permanent.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s1_a3"
},
{
"text": "Stockholm conducted a congestion-charge trial in 2006.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "user_assertion",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a1"
},
{
"text": "The Stockholm city transport office evaluated the 2006 trial using toll-gantry traffic counts.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a2"
},
{
"text": "The Stockholm transport office evaluation found that inner-city traffic dropped by about 20% almost immediately following the trial.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a3"
},
{
"text": "Stockholm made its congestion charge permanent after the 2006 trial.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "user_assertion",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a4"
},
{
"text": "The approximately 20% inner-city traffic reduction in Stockholm persisted after the charge was made permanent.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a5"
},
{
"text": "The Stockholm city transport office evaluated the 2006 congestion-charge trial using toll-gantry traffic counts.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s3_a1"
},
{
"text": "According to the Stockholm city transport office's evaluation, inner-city traffic in Stockholm dropped by about 20% almost immediately after the trial began.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s3_a2"
},
{
"text": "According to the Stockholm city transport office's evaluation, the traffic reduction in inner-city Stockholm was sustained after the congestion charge was made permanent.",
"q_truth": 1,
"source_kind": "cited_source_claim",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s3_a3"
}
],
"stage": "p1"
},
{
"stage": "p2",
"output": {
"routes": [
{
"route_type": "primary_emission",
"variable_id": "v_stockholm_traffic_reduction",
"temp_or_atom_id": "tmp_s1_a2",
"why_this_variable": "The atom directly observes the measured magnitude of Stockholm's inner-city traffic reduction after the congestion-charge trial began.",
"why_not_direct_axis": "It is evidence from one precedent city, not a direct observation of Meridian's expected durable downtown traffic reduction."
},
{
"route_type": "primary_emission",
"variable_id": "v_stockholm_traffic_reduction",
"temp_or_atom_id": "tmp_s1_a3",
"why_this_variable": "The atom directly observes the durability of Stockholm's measured traffic reduction after the charge became permanent.",
"why_not_direct_axis": "It is evidence from one precedent city, not a direct observation of Meridian's expected durable downtown traffic reduction."
}
],
"sc_actions": [
{
"L": 5,
"sc": "Increasing the expected durable reduction in downtown car traffic from a peak-hour cordon charge when side A is chosen strengthens Team A's case.",
"side": "A",
"team": "A",
"sc_id": "sc_durable_traffic_reduction",
"action": "create",
"axis_variable": {
"levels": [
"none",
"small_or_temporary",
"moderate_durable",
"large_durable"
],
"var_id": "v_axis_durable_traffic_reduction",
"definition": "Degree to which adopting a peak-hour downtown cordon charge is expected to produce a durable reduction in car traffic entering or circulating in downtown Meridian.",
"level_centers": {
"none": 0,
"large_durable": 1,
"moderate_durable": 0.6667,
"small_or_temporary": 0.3333
},
"degree_by_level": {
"none": 0,
"large_durable": 5,
"moderate_durable": 3,
"small_or_temporary": 1
}
},
"user_intent_summary": "The user argues that Stockholm is strong precedent for pricing Meridian's cordon because an official toll-gantry-based evaluation found an immediate roughly 20% inner-city traffic drop that persisted after permanent adoption.",
"constructiveness_check": {
"passed": true,
"polarity": "unipolar",
"direction": "increasing",
"qs_flip_result": "sensible_equivalent",
"axis_variable_phrase": "expected durable reduction in downtown car traffic from a peak-hour cordon charge",
"own_goal_repair_needed": false
}
}
],
"uncertainty": {
"level": "medium",
"reasons": [
"The source/method and implementation-context extractions were treated as provenance or background rather than separately routed evidence; the substantive routed issue is the measured Stockholm traffic effect."
]
},
"axis_rule_actions": [
{
"action": "create",
"rule_type": "weighted_mean",
"axis_rule_id": "ar_durable_traffic_reduction",
"input_weights": {
"v_stockholm_traffic_reduction": 1
},
"axis_variable_id": "v_axis_durable_traffic_reduction",
"input_level_values": {
"v_stockholm_traffic_reduction": {
"large_durable_reduction": 1,
"no_reduction_or_increase": 0,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": 0.33,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.67
}
},
"input_variable_ids": [
"v_stockholm_traffic_reduction"
]
}
],
"atom_canonicalization": [
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Source and measurement-method provenance for the Stockholm evaluation, not a standalone outcome observation; its content is retained only as qualifier/context for the created Stockholm traffic-effect atoms.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s1_a1",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "create",
"reason": "Genuinely new factual observation about the measured magnitude of Stockholm's traffic change after a congestion charge.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s1_a2",
"canonical_text": "Stockholm's city transport office's toll-gantry-based evaluation found that inner-city traffic dropped by about 20% almost immediately after the 2006 congestion-charge trial began.",
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "create",
"reason": "Genuinely new factual observation about the durability of Stockholm's measured traffic reduction.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s1_a3",
"canonical_text": "Stockholm's city transport office's toll-gantry-based evaluation found that Stockholm's inner-city traffic reduction persisted after the congestion charge was made permanent.",
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Background fact about the existence of the 2006 trial; it is contextual and subsumed by the created outcome observations, not independently probative.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a1",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Near-duplicate of tmp_s1_a1 within the same extraction batch; source/method provenance is not created as a separate routed atom.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a2",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Near-duplicate of the created immediate traffic-drop observation tmp_s1_a2 within the same extraction batch.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a3",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Background implementation-status fact that is already contextual to the created durability observation and is not independently routed.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a4",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Near-duplicate of the created persistence observation tmp_s1_a3 within the same extraction batch.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s2_a5",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Near-duplicate of tmp_s1_a1 within the same extraction batch; source/method provenance is not created as a separate routed atom.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s3_a1",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Near-duplicate of the created immediate traffic-drop observation tmp_s1_a2 within the same extraction batch.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s3_a2",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
},
{
"action": "reject",
"reason": "Near-duplicate of the created persistence observation tmp_s1_a3 within the same extraction batch.",
"temp_atom_id": "tmp_s3_a3",
"canonical_text": null,
"existing_atom_id": null
}
],
"world_variable_actions": [
{
"kind": "evidence",
"action": "create",
"levels": [
"no_reduction_or_increase",
"small_or_temporary_reduction",
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction",
"large_durable_reduction"
],
"var_id": "v_stockholm_traffic_reduction",
"definition": "How large and durable was the measured inner-city traffic reduction associated with Stockholm's 2006 congestion-charge trial and later permanent charge?",
"granularity_rationale": "This is a city-specific precedent outcome narrower than Meridian's expected effect but broader than any one extraction; future official or independent measurements of the Stockholm outcome should share this variable so repeated reports corroborate without double-counting."
}
]
},
"warnings": [],
"uncertainty": {
"level": "medium",
"reasons": [
"The source/method and implementation-context extractions were treated as provenance or background rather than separately routed evidence; the substantive routed issue is the measured Stockholm traffic effect."
]
}
}
],
"merged": {
"created": {
"tmp_s1_a2": "a_stockholm_s_city_transport_office",
"tmp_s1_a3": "a_stockholm_s_city_transport_office_2"
},
"rejected": [
"tmp_s1_a1",
"tmp_s2_a1",
"tmp_s2_a2",
"tmp_s2_a3",
"tmp_s2_a4",
"tmp_s2_a5",
"tmp_s3_a1",
"tmp_s3_a2",
"tmp_s3_a3"
],
"retired_atoms": [],
"q_truth_updates": {},
"merged_same_fact": {}
},
"bayes_outputs": {
"p3": [
{
"atom_id": "a_stockholm_s_city_transport_office",
"samples": [
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.25
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.25,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.2,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.8,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.4,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 1,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.25,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": -0.25
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.25,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.5
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.25,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.5
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.3,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.6,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.2,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.3
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.75,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.25
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.25,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.5
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.5
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.75,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.25
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.5
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.5
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.25
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.25
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.25
}
],
"averaged": {
"large_durable_reduction": 0.3522727272727273,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.7795454545454544,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.34545454545454546,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.20681818181818185
},
"variable_id": "v_stockholm_traffic_reduction"
},
{
"atom_id": "a_stockholm_s_city_transport_office_2",
"samples": [
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.25,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.25,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.2,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.7,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.6,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": -0.1
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 1,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.75,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.75,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.15,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.4,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.7,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.15
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -1,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.8,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.1
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.25
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.75,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.25,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.75,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.75,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.5
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 1,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -1,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -1,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.25,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.3,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.15
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -1,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.25
},
{
"large_durable_reduction": 0.25,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.5,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.25,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0
}
],
"averaged": {
"large_durable_reduction": 0.5068181818181818,
"no_reduction_or_increase": -0.6863636363636364,
"small_or_temporary_reduction": -0.5954545454545456,
"moderate_or_partly_sustained_reduction": 0.05909090909090909
},
"variable_id": "v_stockholm_traffic_reduction"
}
],
"p4": {
"verdicts": [
{
"reason": "The two atoms address the same factual question—magnitude and durability of Stockholm inner-city traffic reduction from the congestion charge—with one covering immediate size and the other persistence, both needed for the same SC axis role.",
"status": "ok",
"var_id": "v_stockholm_traffic_reduction",
"recommended_action": "keep"
}
],
"warnings": [],
"created_var_ids": [],
"retired_var_ids": []
},
"llm_calls": {
"p1": 3,
"p2": 1,
"p3": 24,
"p4": 1,
"total": 29,
"p3_rescore": 0
},
"touched_vars": [
"v_axis_durable_traffic_reduction",
"v_stockholm_traffic_reduction"
],
"sc_points_after": {
"sc_durable_traffic_reduction": 18.1104168393066
}
}
}